The Alarm
If you have an alarm in your home, you know what it feels like when it goes off in the middle of the night. There is fear, and then the requirement that you make a decision. You will need to get up and investigate what is occurring. Your peaceful night has been disrupted.
Most likely it is nothing; a storm might have blown a window open, or a door latch has come loose.
As the clinical manager of a Planned Parenthood, it was my responsibility to not only wake up if the alarm was sounding but to drive to the clinic and meet the police. For a period of a few months, the alarm sounded almost once a week. We never clearly determined what was causing the alarm; we had the sensors cleaned, and eventually it stopped, I was able to sleep again through the night.
Every time that occurred, I was rattled. It was my responsibility to ensure that the clinical staff and the patients were safe. It shook the clinical team; we were on alert and discussed the events throughout the day.
It distracted us from the work and it slowed us down. It was a wrench in the machine.
The Wrench in the Machine
Fast forward nearly twenty years. I am the case manager in a pediatric transgender center in a massive children’s hospital. I know nothing of social media; I know nothing about the existence of Libs of Tic Toc.
A video from the pediatric center, which had been proudly posted on the hospital’s website, was discovered, clipped, and shared on Twitter by Libs of Tic Toc. It was just like an alarm had gone off and woke us all from our stupor.
Do not underestimate the power of the wrench in the machine. Especially when the machines are complex and huge. The wrench can cause chaos for days.
The video release meant entire departments suddenly not only knew we existed but they were required to stop their usual work. IT had to pull videos, management had to watch the content with a critical eye and review and assess risk in a new way. We had multiple meetings. We shut down the phones in order to plan for what we anticipated would be an onslaught of phone calls.
We discussed this event for at least a month; it rattled the team. It slowed us down. Morale, productivity, and job satisfaction were all impacted. Other divisions that once might have blindly supported us started to consider the other perspectives.
When the alarms are rare, most people will continue the work. They will discuss, maybe even feel more cohesion as a team.
When the alarms become regular, when it begins to feel like a war, when it begins to feel like you are under siege, the cohesion will eventually splinter.
That’s when many teams will fall apart, that’s when some people will walk away, for personal reasons, because they have kids, because something starts to nag at them in the middle of the night. Waking up wondering, am I wrong?
It’s time to become the alarm system in this industry. And we believe we have two pathways forward to do just that. Pathways that we will be rolling out as campaigns that you can engage with. One pathway we are calling Quiet Quitting; one pathway we are calling Direct Action.
The Campaigns
We believe that we will need to pivot into entirely new directions as we have reached an impasse. Twenty five states have laws regulating pediatric gender medicine, but twenty five remain. Most believe that only a potential small handful of states might join in enacting regulations. We need new ideas and new tactics.
We know that many of you have already undertaken activities in your own lives similar to the campaigns that we are rolling out. You have sent letters and information to hospital executives; you might have even already held a sign outside of a clinical space. We want to formalize these into a movement.
We want to help develop ways for you and your affinity groups to raise the alarm and become the wrench. This month we will consider non violent direct action and next month quiet quitting. We welcome you along.
I've been hoping to find an appropriate forum for the following message, and I think I've found one here.
I recently discovered that the patient information page of the online patient interface that two of my doctors use, MyChart, has been influenced by gender identity ideology. I would like to call attention to this problem and share with readers what I am doing about it.
The patient information page in MyChart is an electronic form with pre-determined headings over blank spaces and a pre-determined menu of responses under each heading. The patient fills the blank with the correct choice from the menu and saves the input.
I recently noticed to my dismay that my sex (male) is displayed on that page under the heading "Sex Assigned at Birth."
I also noticed that my sex appears elsewhere on that page under another heading, "Gender Identity." Nooo!
I felt angry and hopeless about the discovery. I was angry that a medical practice had so lost sight of biology and science and its duty to its patients that it had allowed itself to be captured by gender identity ideology. There is absolutely no scientific basis for the notion that doctors routinely "assign" a sex to the infants they deliver. In fact, in all but 0.02 percent of births, the newborn's biological sex is observable and determined by its genitals. Likewise, the idea that people possess gender identities has its roots in philosophy and activism, not science, biology or medicine. I do not want the world to think that I go along with either fiction. I also want to push back against this manifestation of gender identity ideology.
I felt hopeless because the organizations responsible for this distortion of biology and science are large, anonymous, entrenched and have far more resources at their disposal than I do.
Nevertheless, using the message function in MyChart, I sent both organizations my written objection to the erroneous way they are presenting my personal information. I asked them to correct the errors.
This is the message I sent to one of the medical practices. (The message function allows users to specify the type of message they're sending, and in this case I was able to identify mine as a complaint. I did not have that option with the other practice, so I had to send the message to their tech people.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subject: Please correct errors in MyChart's form for my personal information
There are two errors in the online form that MyChart uses to store my personal information. A copy of that form is attached.
Like many people, I reject gender identity ideology. It is activism, not science. It has no place in medicine.
The form gives my "Sex Assigned at Birth." That is incorrect. My sex (M) was biologically determined at the moment of my conception, and it was OBSERVED, not assigned, by the doctor who delivered me in Caracas, Venezuela almost 69 years ago. Only in 0.02% of newborns do doctors assign sex at birth due to ambiguous characteristics.
Please give me the option of selecting "Sex Observed at Birth" or just plain "Sex" so I can correct this erroneous information in my medical records.
2) The form has a space for my "gender identity." I do not have a gender identity. That means I do not "identify as" a male. I AM male. To protest the form, I have selected "Choose not to disclose" from the menu options. That is not satisfactory.
Please add "None" to the menu of options so I can select the option that will make my medical records accurate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As I sent the messages yesterday, Sunday, and today is Monday, I have not yet received any replies.
In the back of my mind there is the fear that if the organizations do not make the changes I am requesting and if I press the matter by escalating it, they might unilaterally terminate their relationship with me. In that case I would have to find a new primary care physician and a new specialist. Small practices are becoming increasingly rare. Chances are that if I found myself without those doctors, any other physicians I might consider would use online patient forms that were shaped by gender ideology in the same way.
Please exercise your own independent judgment in deciding whether and how to respond if you discover that your doctor's office is telling you and anyone else who happens to have access to your personal information that your sex was assigned at birth and that you have a gender identity.
I will try to keep the LGBT Courage Coalition updated on developments in my effort to correct the errors in question, but I cannot promise where or when that might be.
To close on a lighter note, I discovered that each medical practice offers its patients a different list of gender identities to chose from.
One of them, which is a small local practice, let me choose from among the following options:
Choose not to disclose
Female
Male
Non-binary
Other
Transgender Female
Transgender Male
The other is a multi-state behemoth. They probably enlisted hard-core genderqueer or trans activists for help in compiling these whimsical options:
Agender
Choose not to disclose
Demiboy
Demigirl
Female
Gender fluid
Genderqueer
Male
Nonbinary
Other
Transgender Female
Transgender Male
Two Spirit
Unknown (unable to collect)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Demiboy and Demigirl? LOL
Excited to be a part of this effort! Like so many parents entangled in the effects of this ideology, my brain is scrambled and anxious in a way I've never experienced before; nearly all of my energy is sapped in just trying to get my family safely from one day to the next. The energy I have left does not feel like enough to lead any thorough and well thought out "wrench" strategy. I would love for LGBTCC to continue to lead me. Tell me when and where to stick the wrenches and I will make it happen for all of our kids! Nothing would make me happier!